Pittsburgh Steelers 2009 Draft Wrap Up

The Pittsburgh Steelers came into the 2009 NFL draft with pretty much the same team which won the Super Bowl three months earlier.  We can argue about the age of the defensive line or the frequent incompetence of the offensive line but there were no real glaring holes which needed filling immediately.  Director of Player Personnel Kevin Colbert was thus able to come away with a draft short on impact rookies and long on future potential.


Kraig Urbik
Offensive Guard
6’5 330 pounds

A big strong mauler with limited athletic ability and a nasty disposition.  Basically, very similar to Kemo.  Very stout at the point of attack and great at run blocking.  However, his poor footwork and limited mobility will prevent him from pulling or stunting and will cause him to have problems in pass protection.  Might compete with RG Darnell Stapleton for the other guard spot as a rookie which should improve our running game but he’ll have to show he can handle NFL caliber pass rushers in order to stay on the field.

Mike Wallace
Wide Receiver
Ole Miss
6’0 199 pounds

Ran a 4.33 40 at the combine which means he’s almost fast enough to be drafted by Al Davis.  A pure speed burner who was a vertical threat in college.  Unfortunately, he’s unpolished as a WR and needs to work on his route running and hands in order to make it as a wideout.  However, he excelled at kick/punt returns so that’s probably what his primary appeal was to the Steelers.  Think Willie Reid 2.0 but let’s hope he pans out better than Reid did.

Keenan Lewis
Oregon State
6’1 209 pounds

Big and tall corner with the leaping ability to make plays in coverage.  Kind of a poor man’s Ike Taylor, except with less speed and athletic ability.  Ran a 4.53 40 time which puts him at average corner speed and film shows lack of closing speed which allows receivers to create separation.  Also for his size doesn’t play very physical and whiffs on his share of tackles.  A bit of a project as he has the size that teams drool over but will need to be coached up by Tomlin and company in order to work himself into regular playing time.


Joe Burnett
Central Florida
5’9 193 pounds

Dynamic athlete with closing speed, ball skills, and leaping ability.  However, lacks the measurables (ie: height and 40 time) you typically want to see in a corner.  Can make the plays in the secondary if he’s there (10 INTs over the past two seasons) but doesn’t offer much in terms of run support or open field tackling.  Likely was taken more for his abilities as a kick/punt returner as he also filled that role for UCF, averaging 14 yards and scoring 3 TDs over his four year career.  If he doesn’t show a lot as a returner, though, will probably end up as Practice Squad fodder.

Frank Summers
Running Back
5’9 243 pounds

Known as Frank The Tank at UNLV.  Take a look at that picture and tell me who that reminds you of?  The Steeler coaches were all over him at his pro day with several labeling him as a “Junior Bus.”  Incredible strength and his 4.55 40 time is tremendous for a guy of his size and bulk.  A bowling ball with arms and legs who should be very difficult to tackle once he gets a head of steam going.  Many project him as a fullback at the NFL level due to his size and pass catching abilities but I have to think the Steelers will use him as the short yardage RB they’ve sorely missed since the retirement of the original Bus.


Ra’Shon “Sonny” Harris
Defensive Tackle
6’3 300 pounds

Great size and speed.  Very athletically gifted big man who has shown flashes of brilliance.  Problem is these flashes have been few and far between as his game film and career numbers don’t reflect the production you’d expect from somebody with his genetic gifts.  Basically, a classic underachiever who is either lazy or unmotivated.  A project who’ll be a steal if the lightbulb ever turns on for him or who’ll be out of professional football in a couple years due to lack of progress.  It’s all up to him.


A.Q. Shipley
Penn State
6’1 300 pounds

Eric Cartman if he grew up to be a tough, physical, and aggressive football player.  Coach Joe Paterno has frequently said Shipley was a highly intelligent player with great instincts and awareness of what’s going on in the field.  These features compensate for his average to below average physical tools.  Doesn’t have the size you want from an NFL center as he’ll likely be pushed around by mammoth 340 pound nose tackles and defensive linemen.  Good character guy from Moon Township with the kind of work ethic that makes you want to root for him.  Here’s hoping the intangibles prove enough to overcome genetic shortcomings.

David Johnson
Tight End
Arkansas State
6’1 260 pounds

Well, it’s not an official draft unless Colbert takes a tight end. The man has a fetish or something. He can’t stop himself.  Smallish for a tight end with average speed although a strong blocker with good hands.  Might project as a fullback in the Steelers system ala Sean McHugh.  With two TEs already on the roster and McHugh as a FB/TE hybrid, will probably be an uphill battle for him to make this team.

Next Steelers Game View full schedule »
Sunday, Sep 77 Sep1:00Cleveland BrownsBuy Tickets
Dick's Sporting Goods presents "Hell Week":

Tags: 2008 Super Bowl Champions 2009 Nfl Draft 2009 Pittsburgh Steelers 2009 Steeler Draft Picks 2009 Steelers Draft 2009 Steelers Draft Picks 2009 Super Bowl Champions Aq Shipley Dave Johnson Draft Blog Frank The Tank Frank The Tank Summers Franks Summers Joe Burnett Joe Pa Joe Paterno Keenan Lewis Kevin Colbert Kraig Urbik Mike Tomlin Mike Wallace Steelers Mike Wallace Wr Nice Pick Cowher Penn State Pittsburgh Steelers Draft Ra'shon Harris Sonny Harris Steeler Draft Steeler Fans Steeler Nation Steelers Blog Steelers Draft Blog

  • http://NicepickCowher John21

    Hey what do I know compared to the staff of the Super Bowl champs…Answer: Nada! But it is the slow time of year. The draft still has me scratchin my head. So I decided to look at alternate choices. With one exception here is “who else” was available when we picked (& who picked them)

    Rnd 1 #32 Max Unger C/OG (Seattle)
    Rnd 2 #64 Jarron Gilbert DE/DT (Bears)
    Rnd 3 #96 DJ Moore DB (Bears)
    Rnd 4 #128 ScottMcKillop LB (Niners)
    Rnd 5 #168 Herman Johnson OG (ok…he was taken at 167 by Ariz)
    Rnd 5 #169 Dominique Edison WR (Titans)
    Rnd 6 AQ Shipley C (Steel)
    Rnd 7 #241 Marko Mitchell WR (Skins)

    See which draft yeilds more players? I just wanted to see more competition on the O-Line.. Let’s see how it plays out

  • http://nicepickcowher.com chris

    I wasn’t too thrilled with our draft either. But I don’t read Kiper’s newsletter or watch 60 hours of college football per week so I admit my scouting knowledge is very limited.

    My problem was I would rather do like Baltimore did and trade up for one good stud OL than wait until later rounds and hope you find a hidden gem like Colbert seems content to do.

    Your mock draft is interesting but some of those names raise red flags. Gilbert and Moore both were projected as late 1st/early 2nd picks and both fell far. Yeah sometimes guys fall for no reason but if 32 teams passed on them several times, there is probably a reason for it.

    And honestly, I don’t see how your draft yields more players because they addressed every position you did, just in a different order. I agree, though, we’ll have to see how it shakes out, especially going into another year without any significant improvement on the OL.

  • http://NicepickCowher John21

    Here’s how I see it:
    1) Unger is better than Urbik
    2) May take a little longer than Ziggy but I think he has more upside. ( I would have taken Moala if we were set on DL in Rnd 1)
    3) DJ Moore has more skills than Lewis
    4) McKillop is a classic Steeler in a position that has a need with Foote gone.
    The rest of my draft is like the Steelers 50/50 at best. (Though I will be watching the 2 WRs.) I did not focus on the return game like we apparaently did. Like Chris, I do wonder why we didn’t move up and get specific players. Knowing that only 3-4 will make the squad, why not go after fewer with a better chance?
    As we said, we will see…