Dennis Dixon Is The Man

Mike Tomlin has finally made a decision in the Great Quarterback Controversy of 2010.  And it’s really the only choice that makes any sense.  Of course, Tomlin has never let making sense stop him before.  At least this time he has a better than average chance of being right.

Dennis Dixon will start the season opener against the Atlanta Falcons.  This must be a bittersweet victory for DD since he’s being handed the job by default.  Tomlin seemed hellbent on flushing the first four games of the year down the toilet with Byron Leftwich at the controls.  As a result, Dixon has had limited snaps with the first team offense and wasn’t given the preparation a young quarterback with unlimited potential deserves.  Make no mistake, Tomlin’s waffling created much of this mess and if Dix commits any rookie mistakes, those failures will be on his indecisive head coach and not him.

While I fully expect there will be some growing pains due to his inexperience, there’s no question Slash 2.0 was the best option to start the season.  Charlie Batch hasn’t started a game in three years.  He’s only taken four regular season snaps in that time while breaking his wrist playing basketball getting up off the ground.  He’s done absolutely no work with the first team offense so there is no way you can expect him to step in and run the Flying Circus effectively.  Perhaps if he were given a fair shot in the QB Derby from the get-go, he would’ve demonstrated why he’s been the best back up in the NFL the past seven years.   At this point, the Batch ship has sailed.

In a related matter, the Pittsburgh Steelers named their team captains for the upcoming season.  The players voted on who they wanted representing them and their selections speak volumes about the respect, or lack thereof, they have for some of their teammates.  James Farrior (defense), Keyaron Fox (special teams), and Heath Miller and Hines Ward (offense) were elected.  Selecting Farrior, a respected veteran, Fox, a blue collar jack-of-all-trades, and Hines, one of the greatest men on AND OFF the field to ever wear the Black and Gold was a clear message to last year’s captains.  James Harrison, Jeff Reed, and Ben Roethlisberger have all disgraced themselves and their team to varying degrees over the past couple years and it’s nice to see their teammates hold them accountable for their poor behavior by stripping them of that honor.  Let’s hope all three have learned their lessons once and for all.

In the meantime, Team Dixon has gotten their wish.  The most exciting young quarterback in the NFL is finally being given his chance to shine.  Let’s hope his performance justifies all the faith we’ve placed in him.  And, at the very least, let’s hope his play keeps the ship afloat long enough for Big Ben to return and lead the team on a glorious run to the playoffs.

Next Steelers Game View full schedule »
Sunday, Sep 77 Sep1:00Cleveland BrownsBuy Tickets
Dick's Sporting Goods presents "Hell Week":

Tags: 2009 Nfl Playoffs Baltimore Ravens Ben Roethlisberger Big Ben Black And Gold Black And Gold Blog Byron Leftwich Charlie Batch Dennis Dixon Dixon Starter Dixon Starts For Steelers Fast Willie Parker Fwp Heath Miller Hines Ward James Harrison Lamarr Woodley Mike Tomlin Nfl Playoffs Pittsburgh Pittsburgh Steelers Pittsburgh Steelers Blog Rashard Mendenhall Ratbirds Ravens-Steelers Roethlisberger Roethlisberger Concussion Santonio Holmes Slash 2.0 Steeler Nation Steelers Steelers Blog Steelers Nation Stillers Super Bowl Champions Tomlin Names Starter

  • Tom G

    Well, I hope you’re right. I have mixed feelings about the situation, but agree with Ron Cook’s article today and would have gone with Batch. On the flip side, I do think it’s time to make Dixon prove his ability. If you can’t depend on him, it’s time to start shopping for a new backup. I really looking forward to Sunday…

    • chris

      Like I said in my prior response to you, if you start a guy who was going to be CUT over the guy who was supposedly “competing” for the starting job, there’s something really wrong there. And I truly think Dixon is going to surprise people, assuming Arians gives him a decent game plan. Dix battled the Ravens to a standstill on 24 hours notice last season, I don’t get why people are forgetting that.

      As for Ron Cook, I have not read that article but I stay away from the P-G’s columnists (notice I link to their reporting since I don’t have access but I stay away from their editorials). To be honest, all the media in this town is either woefully out-of-touch or write from Steelers approved scripts to which I can’t take most of it too seriously.

      • Tom G

        Agreed. I did forget about the Baltimore game, and was just talking with my brother, who said the same exact thing as you about choosing Dixon over someone who was being cut. I’m on board with the Dixon decision. Cheers, Tom

  • http://nicepickcowher Tacky

    Hey, it’s your blog so you’re entitled to censor comments but it seems if you don’t like somethin’ someone says you decide not to post…As opposed to creating a forum for all kinds of opinions…Seems to prove my point about your overwhelming negativity.

    • chris

      Opinions are fine. Disagreement with what I write is fine. What is not fine is trolling such as name-calling or blatant insults which serve no point and don’t contribute anything to the discussion.

      Think of this blog as a sports radio talk show. If you called in to your favorite show and began your comment by taunting the host and then proceeded to call him a racist, you’d be cut off almost immediately. Deleting troll comments is my form of hanging up on immature callers.

      As for being “negative,” that’s your opinion. If you bother to read the Super Bowl XL post in my Greatest Hits section at bottom, I get called a blatant homer by Seattle fans. If you’re looking for a blog which is nothing more than idiotic cheerleading while ignoring anything negative about the Steelers, then look elsewhere. I simply tell it like it is, both the good and the bad.

  • Daniel Watchorn

    LOVE this website!