Taylor, Lewis and Gay - are these guys for real?

Thursday's Poll: Steelers' Secondary - Real Deal or Hardly Tested?


With the offensive line and run defense under the microscope of criticism since the first week, praises are far and few what was and is working for the Steelers – the secondary.  Earlier this week, NPC featured an article discussing Keenan Lewis and his ‘success’ over the early part of this season.  There’s been a little bit of mixed reaction from readers on Lewis’ play, and an even more mixed bag when it comes to talking about the secondary in general.  So how good is this secondary, really?

Statistically, the secondary is the best part of the defense.  In fact, the secondary has been ranked #1 in the league in yards allowed per game at a whopping 174 yds.  And, even though the rush defense is ranked 18th with 108.8 yds per, the overall yards allowed from the defense is 2nd in the league at 282.8 yds.  That’s some impressive numbers.  But is there a bit of falsehood that lies within these stats?  Anyone who puffs their chest out and touts that the Steelers have the best passing defense in the legue is quickly faced with a ‘yeah, but.’

‘Yeah, but the Steelers secondary has not faced a high powered passing offense.’  Touche.  Their first real test as a defense would have come against Manning and the Colts, but there was no Manning.  But what about Matt Hasselbeck and the Titans.  Coming into that game, Matty and the Titans were on a three game winning streak.  Hasselbeck passed for over 300 yards in each of those games, and the offense scored 17 points or more each game as well (with Hasselbeck throwing for at least 1 TD per game).  Their passing offense was ranked 8th in the league – that’s nothing to scoff at, right?  Aside from a few blown coverages here and there (of which I was fairly critical of) the secondary and LB’s dropping back into coverage did a fairly good job keeping the Titan receivers under control.  Hell, you hardly ever heard Taylor’s, Lewis’ or Gay’s name all game.  Is Dan Dierdorf in denial?

But can that game justify the ranking?  Has the secondary been ‘truly tested’ this season?  They play Jacksonville next, and they have the worst offense in the league (ranked 32nd and 31st in passing yards and points respectively), then the Cardinals (ranked 16th in passing) and then the Patriots (ranked 1st in passing and total yards and 2nd in points… yipes).  So will the next two games give the team a false sense of security and hope while three weeks from now the high powered Patriots will be poised to blast the secondary off the face of the Heinz Field?  I won’t hold my breath during that Patriots game.  But, as for the first five weeks and what’s to come in the next two – I think we can all feel a little relieved that what was perceived as a huge problem since the Super Bowl is not as bad as we thought. In fact, the secondary is looking pretty good.  We are talking about the NFL and good receivers and quarterbacks on teams.  Even mediocre QB’s can expect to get a decent amount of yards when passing to the likes of someone like Reggie Wayne – especially since the Steelers front men have had a very difficult time putting any pressure on the quarterback.

Maybe these guys are finally developing into good cover corners.  The interceptions aren’t there, but the stats of shutting down receivers are.  Maybe Carnell Lake was the missing link to all of this.  Now, I’m sure they will have their struggles over the season – no defense is perfect.  But, this secondary has shown much promise for the season to come…. and dare I say that they may be the saviors to this poor performing pass rush and run defense?

So what do you think Nation?  Is this secondary the real deal or just hyped up and weakly tested?

Steelers' Secondary: Real Deal or Hardly Tested?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Next Steelers Game View full schedule »
Sunday, Sep 77 Sep1:00Cleveland BrownsBuy Tickets
Dick's Sporting Goods presents "Hell Week":

  • CoverCorner

    Yeah, its early in the season, but you have to play your schedule. Tough they haven’t faced their toughest competion yet, I wouldn’t say they haven’t been tested. I thought they looked good even in the lost to Houston. Fans are always quicker to decide something is broke, then accepting something as fixed….which isn’t necessarily a bad thing. The next month will be big for them, and I’m predicting they will do well.

  • CoverCorner

    Yeah, its early in the season, but you have to play your schedule. Tough they haven’t faced their toughest competion yet, I wouldn’t say they haven’t been tested. I thought they looked good even in the lost to Houston. Fans are always quicker to decide something is broke, then accepting something as fixed….which isn’t necessarily a bad thing. The next month will be big for them, and I’m predicting they will do well.

  • Pingback: Awesome Articles From Awesome Steelers Blogs October 13, 2011 « Pittsburgh Steel Foundry - The Ultimate Pittsburgh Steelers Blog

  • EyeInTheSky

    This is the NFL. “On any given Sunday…”. Can’t put to much on who they played. The Seahawks knocked the Saints out the playoffs last year, who’d a thunk it.

    I gotta go by what I see, and so far that’s been some great coverage on some great receivers, very, very little YAC, no long passes, even a couple coverage sacks. I see young guys, old guys, and backups playing well. I’m seeing improvement every week.

    Being a “glass half full” kinda guy, I think we have to say they’re the real deal until somebody proves otherwise.

    This week, Gabbert is a rookie, but Mercedes Lewis is not, Hill and Thomas are young and fast, then they get Kolb, Fitzgerald and Doucet, then Brady and that group, Flacco and his guys. Its going to be a big month for Lake’s bunch. So for those that need to see them “tested”, here we go. I think they’ll do well.

  • EyeInTheSky

    This is the NFL. “On any given Sunday…”. Can’t put to much on who they played. The Seahawks knocked the Saints out the playoffs last year, who’d a thunk it.

    I gotta go by what I see, and so far that’s been some great coverage on some great receivers, very, very little YAC, no long passes, even a couple coverage sacks. I see young guys, old guys, and backups playing well. I’m seeing improvement every week.

    Being a “glass half full” kinda guy, I think we have to say they’re the real deal until somebody proves otherwise.

    This week, Gabbert is a rookie, but Mercedes Lewis is not, Hill and Thomas are young and fast, then they get Kolb, Fitzgerald and Doucet, then Brady and that group, Flacco and his guys. Its going to be a big month for Lake’s bunch. So for those that need to see them “tested”, here we go. I think they’ll do well.

  • craig.gottschalk

    @EyeInTheSky Yes the impressive hardly talked about stat within the secondary is the low YAC. If/when receivers are making catches, the secondary is wrapping them up. Also shows great support from the safeties to get there when needed.

  • craig.gottschalk

    @EyeInTheSky Yes the impressive hardly talked about stat within the secondary is the low YAC. If/when receivers are making catches, the secondary is wrapping them up. Also shows great support from the safeties to get there when needed.