Signing Jerricho Cotchery, Not Emmanuel Sanders, Should Be Top Priority

Mandatory Credit: Jason Bridge-USA TODAY Sports

 

Nine months ago, the Pittsburgh Steelers were offered a third round pick as compensation for Sanders from the wide receiver-needy New England Patriots.

I thought the potential move was a risky gambit, especially since the Steelers had some question marks at the wide receiver position entering the 2013 regular season. Nevertheless, a third round draft choice was the highest price tag they would likely receive for Sanders if they allowed the impending free agent (2014) to walk.

Make no mistake, Sanders has enjoyed a career-year in terms of production (58 catches, 661 yards, and five touchdowns) during what is his fourth professional season. However, it is the crafty veteran Jerricho Cotchery, not Sanders, who should be in line for a contract extension from the Steelers’ brass this spring.

You can throw all of the ‘age,’ ‘upside,’ and ‘explosiveness’ nonsense in Sanders’ defense that you want. I will not deny that Sanders has the edge over Cotchery in those particular areas. Nevertheless, I would rather see the Steelers’ front office make a concerted effort to ink the more reliable veteran with better hands who is a far superior red zone target than the more expensive youngster.

I am not advocating that Cotchery needs to replace Sanders in the starting lineup next fall. The number two role opposite Antonio Brown would be best filled by Markus Wheaton or a high round choice in the upcoming draft.

Yet in today’s passing NFL, a competent third wide receiver is something that every offense must have at their disposal. As nice as it would be to bring Sanders back, Cotchery’s production (41 catches, 571 yards, nine touchdowns, 34 first downs) and price tag (ending two-year contract worth $3 million) make him a far more attractive option for Pittsburgh to pursue.

In addition to his on-field production, Cotchery also has the potential to be a valuable locker room presence during Pittsburgh’s rebuilding era. Cotchery could be a perfect guy to mentor Pittsburgh’s younger pass-catchers, and is someone who could provide advice to guys like Wheaton, Justin Brown, and Derek Moye while go through their early-career growing pains.

So please, Kevin Colbert. Let Sanders walk, recoup an eventual compensatory pick for him and make a sensible football and financial decision for your cap-strapped franchise. Cotchery needs to stay, Sanders does not.

 

 

 

 

Stats & Contract Info. Provided By: ESPN.comSteelers.com , Spotrac, and Pro Football Reference

 

Follow on Twitter: @DominicDiTolla and @NicePickCowherC

Like “NPC” on Facebook: Nice Pick, Cowher

Topics: Emmanuel Sanders, Jerricho Cotchery, Pittsburgh Steelers

Want more from Nice Pick, Cowher?  
Subscribe to FanSided Daily for your morning fix. Enter your email and stay in the know.
  • Joe Longo

    Not to mention of all the key drops that sanders has had for us.

  • bk

    Agreed.. maybe pick up another late round project in the draft..A guy I relly like that will probably not be drafted is a kid from Boise St, Miller.. not a burner, but catches everything and is big and runs good routes.. a nice #4 or 5 receiver and a special team player. Also need another TE… maybe get Jack Niclaus’s grandson out of FSU…O’leary?

    • Dom DiTolla

      Steelers already have two #4 or #5 guys on their roster/practice squad to develop in the forms of Derek Moye and Justin Brown. If they go WR, they’ll grab one early (Evans, Watkins, Adams, Matthews, or even Benjamin if he declares) to plug in since Wheaton could be a starter if both Cotchery and Sanders bolt.

      Nicklaus’ grandson, O’Leary, is also only a junior so he could wait to come out. Steelers need an explosive player at that position though.