Mandatory Credit: Jeff Hanisch-USA TODAY Sports

Mike Tomlin Defends Late Game Touchdown Strategy


 

 

I am not into that. We had the opportunity to put the ball in the end zone. In weather conditions like that, anything can happen. The snapper could roll the ball back, the ball could roll through the snappers hands, etc. Given the opportunity to score, we’re going to score [not run time off to kick a game-winning field goal]. We felt comfortable putting our defense on the field and winning.

-Mike Tomlin (Steelers.com)

 

I understand that the Pittsburgh Steelers won yesterday, and it makes me smile to see that the team is still in contention for a postseason berth. However, it is really difficult for me to digest what occurred at the end of the game when it came to the clock management by Pittsburgh’s coaching staff and their offense.

Instead of winding the clock down and sending Shaun Suisham on the field to make what could have been a less than 25-yard field goal, Mike Tomlin wanted his team to try for a go-ahead touchdown with close to 1:30 remaining in the game. Make no mistake, I am happy that Le’Veon Bell scored on a one-yard touchdown run on second and goal. Nevertheless, I felt that Tomlin’s decision to go for the touchdown with that amount of time remaining was a ridiculous gamble.

I for one would have had my reservations with the way the defense had been shredded by Matt Flynn for 31 points to that point in the game. Instead of a sieve-like defense, I would have rather rolled the dice on my veteran long snapper in the form of Greg Warren, a veteran holder Mat McBriar and a reliable kicker in the form of Suisham. An attempted field goal itself would have been a glorified extra point for one of the league’ most accurate kickers inside of 45 yards this fall.

Plus, who is to say that Bell doesn’t put the ball on the turf on his way into the end zone? He fumbled earlier in the game, and the conditions were not exactly prime for running backs at that particular juncture. Roethlisberger could have mishandled the snap from the shotgun formation, or even botched the exchange with Bell.

As far as giving the ball back to the Packers with close to a minute and a half was concerned, did it not occur to Tomlin that Micah Hyde is currently one of the NFL’s best kickoff return men? Moreover, why didn’t special teams coach Danny Smith instruct Suisham to pooch the ball to an up-back with limited ball skills? Heck, Shamarko Thomas deserves credit for his effort on the play and how he saved the game with the timely tackle of Hyde.

Now I completely understand that the Packers did not have any timeouts remaining. Yet 1:25 is an eternity for an NFL offense to move the ball eighty yards for a score or to at least move the ball far enough for a shot into the end zone. Unless Suisham booted it out of the end zone on the kickoff, the Packers would have had ample time and potentially good field position to work with at that juncture.

Thankfully for the Steelers, Tomlin’s decision did not backfire on him or his team because of Green Bay’s piss-poor clock management. Had Matt Flynn knew the 10-second runoff rule, the Packers likely would have had another offensive play or even two to run inside Pittsburgh’s 10-yard line at the end of the game.

While I must give credit to Tomlin for sticking to his guns and standing by his decision, it would have been nice to see him show more faith in his kicker, punter/holder and long snapper to put the game away yesterday.

 

 

Stats & Contract Info. Provided By: ESPN.comSteelers.com , Spotrac and Pro Football Reference

 

Follow on Twitter: @DominicDiTolla and @NicePickCowherC

Like “NPC” on Facebook: Nice Pick, Cowher

Tags: Mike Tomlin Pittsburgh Steelers

  • William Cross

    Haha, wow!

  • jmd123

    Couldnt agree more with this article! Tomlin sounds like he’s making excuses for his poor management of the clock which is funny cosidering he is always preaching his team will make no excuses in what seems to be every other week when they walk away with a loss. I also find it interesting to note Bell had already fumbled in that game while Suisham had no problem splitting the posts 5 times prior that day yet the kick was a bigger risk….

  • Carl Eagan

    What did you expect? Mike Tomlin standing in front of people and say yeah I screwed up with that call which was obviously what the packers wanted since they didn’t try very hard to stop Bell. Along with team preparation, keeping track of timeouts, and knowing where the field is and game and clock management is not one of Mike Tomlin’s strengths.

    • bk

      About the same odds of that happening as Obama saying he made a mistake… on anything….ever……..

  • Karl Thayer

    I’m sorry,but I have to agree on going for the TD. Greenbay had already had a 23 yd field goal blocked in the game. Also I remember how money Suisham was in the Oakland game.

    • Craig

      Blocking a field goal is about as frequent as my farts not smelling bad. They don’t happen very often and it’s even poorer strategy to even make that as part of your argument – hey we blocked one field goal today, why not do something even more rare and block another in the same game. Suisham kicked 5 times from that same spot all afternoon and was money.

      Dom is right that Flynn, Lacy and Starks sliced up this defense all day. They were lucky Flynn didn’t see Nelson wiiiiiiiiide open in the endzone at the end of the game or the Steelers would have lost. Tomlin could have looked like a genius by running down the clock. Instead even with the win he looks like a doofus.